AI Agents

Gemini Tasks vs Meta Muse: What Paul J Lipsky Found

Paul J Lipsky asked Gemini to call his climbing gym about holiday hours. Calling wasn't enabled on his account. About 45 minutes later, Gemini texted back: it had looked for the schedule, hadn't found it, and offered to draft an email instead. In other tests it did the work but never texted that it was done. Lipsky had to ask for an update.

That contrast explains why Tasks in Gemini is useful but not yet a replacement for Meta Muse in Lipsky's setup. Texting makes it easy to hand off a job. The question is whether you can tell what happened next without chasing the agent yourself.

Watch Paul Test Gemini Tasks

Source Note: The hands-on observations come from Paul J Lipsky's 19 November 2026 video and transcript. Eligibility and setup were checked against Google and Meta's public documentation on 19 November. Semrush at 05:30 is the video's sponsor segment, separate from the tests.

Who Gets Task, Text and Email?

Google's 17 November update brought more of the agent workflow into the Gemini app's Chat / Task switch, powered at rollout by Gemini 4 Hydrogen. Lipsky sees it as the successor to the earlier Gemini Spark experience. You don't need to look for a separate app named Task.

ChannelWhat Google lists
Task modeNo subscription required in Australia, Canada, India, Japan, South Korea and the US. Other supported markets require Google AI Pro or Ultra, except where Tasks are unavailable: the EEA (including Portugal), Nigeria, Switzerland and the UK.
TextingUS personal Google account set to English, Task access, an eligible US mobile number and RCS. Android and iPhone have different Messages requirements.
EmailUS personal Google account with Tasks, using the same account in Gemini and Gmail, with the email channel enabled. For creating tasks, not for tracking an ongoing conversation.

Google's eligibility guide also lists a minimum age of 18, a personal rather than work or school account, and Keep Activity enabled. Don't buy a paid plan assuming it unlocks an excluded country or the US-only channels. Check what is available in your account during the rollout.

Set Up Task, RCS and Gmail

  1. Start in Gemini. Open the app or Gemini on the web, start a new conversation and switch from Chat to Task. Start with something you can verify yourself.
  2. Set up texting on your phone. In Gemini go to Settings → Channels → Text with Gemini, then follow the number verification and onboarding prompts. On Android use Google Messages with RCS on and the same account and number. On iPhone enable RCS Messaging and RCS Business Messages. Using Apple's Messages app doesn't make the conversation an end-to-end encrypted iMessage; Google says the agent's texts are not end-to-end encrypted.
  3. Turn on email separately. Enable Email with Gemini in Channels. From the matching Gmail account, manually forward a test message with gemini@google.com in To and state what you want done. Gemini replies with a link to the new task. Google's help page says CC/BCC alone and automatic forwarding aren't supported, despite the CC suggestion in the video. Use the task link or text thread for follow-up rather than starting another email task.

Connect only the apps your first job needs. Avoid putting passwords, payment details or sensitive correspondence directly into the task thread. For a first test, skip payments and account-wide inbox access.

What Worked and What Stalled

TestWhat Lipsky observed
Text to presentationAfter asking about reactions to an OpenAI release, he followed up by asking for a presentation. Gemini produced a Google Slides deck. Check sources and claims before sharing a generated deck.
Call the climbing gymNo call was made on his account. Gemini later said the public schedule didn't answer the question and offered to draft an inquiry. That's a useful fallback, not confirmed holiday hours.
Shopping dashboardA text request for an AirPods price tracker returned a dashboard link opening in Gemini. The video shows the dashboard, not proof that its daily updates ran reliably or that anything was bought.
App to textHe started a story in Task mode, then asked for its first paragraph over text. Gemini found it. He distinguishes this from asking about an ordinary Chat conversation.
Completion messagesSome longer requests were acknowledged without a completion message. When he asked again, the work was sometimes already done. Check the original task before resubmitting anything that could create a duplicate.

Calls and checkout are separate capabilities. Google announced business calling and Google Pay checkout as advanced features rolling out starting in the US. The announcement excludes calling in Indiana, Louisiana, Minnesota, Montana and Nebraska. Google's own Instacart example ends with a handoff to the user to finish checkout. Neither Paul's unavailable call nor his price dashboard demonstrates autonomous purchases. Review any booking or checkout in the original service before confirming it.

Gemini Tasks vs Meta Muse

Try Gemini first when the job starts in Gmail or ends in a Google file. The Slides demo is a good example. Lipsky found that the phone's continuous text conversation felt more like a personal assistant than opening separate Task threads in the Gemini app. That describes the interface, not a guarantee that the agent remembers every past conversation.

Try Muse when you want a dedicated agent in the Muse app or WhatsApp and your workflow depends on connectors it supports. Lipsky prefers Muse's named assistant and found it worked with more of the third-party tools he wanted. That isn't a verified count of connectors or a model-quality ranking. Try the same job on both and compare the finished result, the number of follow-ups and how clearly each handles approvals.

Watch Paul's separate Meta Muse walkthrough

Read our breakdown of his seven Muse tests.

A Low-Risk First Task

Give both agents a request they can answer with public information. A good result provides a source, says when the information isn't confirmed, and doesn't take an extra action. It also tells you when it's finished.

JQ AI SYSTEMS starter prompt

Check holiday hours without calling

Ready to copy

Video Chapters

TimeTopic
00:00Intro
00:31Who gets access
01:06Texting and tasks
04:07Email and payments
05:30Semrush (sponsor)
06:46Why Task mode feels less personal
09:19Set up Gemini
11:26More features and limits
13:46Gemini vs Muse
Share
X LinkedIn Reddit
Build Yours

Want a system
like this one?

Book a free 30-minute call. We map your situation, identify the highest-impact automation, and figure out if we are a fit.

Book Free 30-min Call